I like art. Big surprise right? I see it everywhere. I like splashes of color. I like textures. I like patterns. I like just the right grouping of words, just the right angle in a photo, just the right gathering of musical notes, just the right sprinkling of sugar on top of a scone. I like sharp contrast and messy edges. I like beautiful snippets from everyday life.
But there is this problem that sometimes weasels its way into my enjoyment of art. I suppose it could be labeled as envy. Yes, that is it, if it should be given a name.
It’s interesting to me that one of my strengths is that I am an achiever. And while that achieving strength is layered with all sorts of good qualities like having a great deal of stamina and being a hard driven, busy and productive worker, it also comes with what has been described as a “whisper of discontent.”
And here is where the interesting bit comes in…compare my strength with the definition of ENVY.
Envy – a feeling of discontent or covetousness with regard to another’s advantages, success, possessions, etc.
By nature, one of my greatest strengths can also rear it’s ugly head as one of my greatest weaknesses.
And I must confess, I have to fight that whisper of discontent as an artist because I have a hard time letting my favorite artists just be my favorite artists. If I discover some new art, I don’t want to just enjoy it, I want it as my own. I feel some sort of competitive spirit rise up within me, the winds of discontent begin to blow and I think, oh, I could make art like that. Surely. And then I seek to not only try and make that art, but to, in some ways, become that person.
This all came pouring out one night as I sat across from Tony in Panera watching him sip on a chai latte. I love how he can coax things out of me that I’m struggling with and then bring some sense and clarity and hope to it all.
So I think this post could really be a series of posts, as I seek to unearth the artist I really should be, instead of all the artists I have tried to be. But for now, let’s just start with this simple and incredibly humbling confession.
I am not Ali Edwards.
I am not Elsie Flannigan.
I am not Keri Smith.
I am not Sabrina Ward Harrison.
I am not Penelope Dullaghan.
I am not Donald Miller.
I am not Pomplamoose.
I am not my artistic contacts in Flickr or Twitter or Facebook.
I am not _____.
And I have not been able to fully enjoy all of your beautiful art fully because there has been a piece of me, at one time or another, trying so hard to be you.
I am letting that go.
I am attempting to ignore my whisper of discontent, though I fear, in this life, I will never be able to completely silence it.
Even though I want to achieve it all, I realize that what results is me dangerously spinning my wheels. I flit from one art medium to another. I try and wear her shoes and then his shoes. I try everything and enjoy nothing. I don’t enjoy my art and I don’t enjoy others art. And that’s sad, because as I told you at the beginning of this post, I like art.
I am on a journey to find the artist Mandy Steward.















{ 21 comments… read them below or add one }
I am right there with you on this topic. So often, instead of simply enjoying my friendships or admiring a mentor I find myself wanting to be like THEM instead of being who God wants ME to be. We are each uniquely created and uniquely creative. Thanks for the reminder to make art instead of envying it.
Omg, I feel like you’re describing me. Get out of my head!
Seriously, thanks for sharing this very authentic and lovely post. Blessings to you on your journey.
Great thoughts. I’m right there with you. I think this is something all artists struggle with, if they are being honest with themselves…the trick is learning how to let others inspire us…and then take that inspiration and make something new that’s OURS instead of trying to imitate. It’s a life-long battle, if you ask me.
I loved this. Really. Can I echo your words and the words of your friends here? Yes…discovering ourselves as unique artists…uniquely and intentionally crafted.
Thanks Mandy!
~veronica
Gosh, I’m the same way and I really don’t like it! Sometimes, I have to MAKE myself stop looking. At other artists, other inspiration, etc. to really bring me back to what makes me unique and allow me to spur on my own creativity.
I too struggle with this all the time, I feel that I haven’t found my art yet. I am a very good copyist, but what is it that I am too create? What will people imitate that I make? I remember from art class in college, the professor said that Pablo Picasso made a bull’s head out of bicycle parts and someone said of his art “I could make that” and Picasso said, ‘yes. but it would only be a copy of mine’. Sometimes, I just want one Picasso moment!:)
Daniel, Why are we like that? I’m so tired of being like that.
LeAnne, Good, I’m so glad you can relate. Blessings on your journey as well!
Abbi – Yes, a life-long war with several battles along the way…some of which we will win. Hopefully many that we will win.
Veronica – You’re welcome!
Evie – And here I thought you would never relate to this post. *sigh* of relief that you are in fact human as well.
Christina – Wow, I’ve never heard that about Picasso. I love that. The search for “your art” can be maddening, can’t it? And yet, it’s better I think to search than to just give up. So keep searching. You are wildly creative. I hope you can settle into something feels beautifully Christina-ish. I know you have it in you. (By the way, I WILL take pictures of the book you made me. I keep forgetting!)
I can so relate to this Mandy! It takes a lot of effort to just be me sometimes instead of like everyone else!
You are so awesome for putting this into words. Thank you.
Awesome!
This post speaks to me as well! But alas, the greatest form of flattery is imitation….but
balanced I guess.
A while back I posted something similar to this on my blog… It’s a quick read.
It’s the destruction nature of envy-
http://geeden.blogspot.com/2007/10/dennis-prager-happiness-hour.html
I love the work you do Mandy. But who would be you, when you’re
being Ali???
Shalae – Isn’t it funny that it seems to take more effort to just be ourselves. That seems like it should be the easier route.
Vanessa and Roz – Thank you. I love to process thoughts with written words, and I love even more when others can relate to it. Makes it so worthwhile and fulfilling. So thanks for the encouragement.
Eden – I tell my kids this all the time. Who would do it Miah’s way or Charis’ way or Zoe’s way if they don’t? It applies to me as well.
Mandy, I think all women struggle with this in some capacity in their lives- whether it’s art, parenting, material possessions, etc. It’s such a stronghold that Satan has over us! It’s hard to be on both sides of the fence as Christians- a battle to not envy and a battle to try to not seek out others’ envy. I’ve totally been on both sides and man oh man is it hard to retreat from but I’m right there with you to. I’m guarding what I look at as well as my own words (especially in the online world) to not only not envy others but also not stir up envy in others’ hearts and trying to shift my focus. It’s a hard thing to do… :/ Thank you so much for pointing out the Message version of Galatians 6:4- how appropriate!!!! Love it!
Mandy,
Thanks for this post. Really good, very honest thoughts. It takes a lot of courage to name some of your “I am not’s.” I’m sitting here thinking that’s probably an important part of the healing/growing process. It’s scary to name those. It makes me think, “What if my fans/clients/friends see my inspiration and think less of me?” “What if they don’t think I’m as original and/or creative as they do now.” “If they see _____’s work/art, they might choose them instead.”
Competitiveness, (closely related to envy for me too), definitely steals my peace and joy. It’s ugly and it makes me all knotted-up inside. Maybe I need to publish a list of “I’m not’s?”
Thank you. I will definitely be following your blog.
Amber – I don’t think it’s just women, although we women can tend to be “catty.” I’m with you, trying to shift my focus. Be content with who I heard God telling me to be and in that contentment not falling into thinking I’m better than others. Back and forth. Searching for the balance. Tired of weebling and wobbling back and forth.
Justin – And thank you for your honesty. Yes, the “I am nots” were terribly hard to write. I don’t want people to know that I want to be someone else…especially not THOSE people. Now I don’t know that they read my blog anyway, but I did link to them, so they could have clicked back through to see who was pointing people to their blogs. At any rate, it’s humbling to admit and yet you are right, so healing at the same time. Healing to confess and move on. It’s a new day, and I’m a new creation. Let the old go, let the new come. Not that it won’t rear it’s ugly ahead again sometime, but each day is a new chance. Thank God. Glad for your comment and glad you’ll keep reading Messy Canvas.
Yep yep yep.
I want to copy this. I wished I had said it. I actually have thought it so many times but now, you put it into words and it touched me somewhere deep. Because it is me but I just couldn’t express it. Don’t you think that’s what we do with other artist. They express something in us that we don’t have the skill or the life experience or the .. (whatever) – we just don’t have it. But then they give it to us and want to claim it as our own because it was always there waiting for someone to show it to us. THanks for showing me what I needed to see in myself but couldn’t get out.
Great post Mandy – I love that you’re talking about this stuff!!
I just had a terrible week thinking about that!!! thank you for sharing this I am so with you I have this struggle with imitation, there’s a thin line between be inspired by the artist and trying to BE the artist you feel inspired with . I want to hung up to that and really be me!!! in the way I am feeling it BELIEVE in my own strenght my own magic, my own life . God bless you for share this.
You hit it right on the nail. One of my “strengths” is achiever and I so struggle and battle with this…battle with wanting to either become them or to just stop creating at all because I’ll never be “good enough” which there isn’t ever a tangible line. So interesting about the definition of envy…didn’t know that or make that connection before, but it makes so much sense. Off to go ponder how I can let go of the I am not ___’s in my life.
Yeah, I’m really bad about saying if I can’t do it all the way I just won’t do it at all (in lots of areas of my life). Trying to work on that.
{ 8 trackbacks }